OptinMonster vs Popup Maker
An independent, review-free comparison compiled by the SaaSTracker editorial team. Both products are profiled in full, and neither can pay for placement here.
Still shortlisting? Browse the best in Lead Capture & Popups for every option we track, with award winners called out.
The short answer
Both sides assessedOptinMonster compared with Popup Maker
Popup Maker is the WordPress-native alternative with no traffic meter at all: the core plugin is free with unlimited popups and impressions, and exit intent, scroll triggers, analytics, and advanced targeting cost $99 a year per site on Pro. OptinMonster keeps the deeper rules engine, the larger template library, A/B testing, and a hosted service that works beyond WordPress. For a high-traffic WordPress site on a fixed budget, Popup Maker is hard to beat; for testing-led campaigns or non-WordPress sites, OptinMonster is the one to buy.
Popup Maker compared with OptinMonster
The two best-known WordPress popup names, with opposite business models. OptinMonster is a hosted service connected through a plugin, with a deeper rules engine, a larger template library, and A/B testing on higher tiers, priced on campaign impressions and sites with introductory pricing that renews at list. Popup Maker runs inside WordPress, charges a flat annual license with no traffic meter, and costs nothing for the basics. Choose OptinMonster for testing and campaign polish; choose Popup Maker when traffic is high, budget is fixed, and WordPress is the only platform.
Choose OptinMonster if
Content sites, ecommerce stores, and agencies that already have meaningful traffic and want granular control over which visitor sees which offer, and that will pay for a targeting engine rather than settle for a generic popup builder.
Choose Popup Maker if
WordPress sites, especially content sites, membership sites, course creators on LifterLMS, and WooCommerce stores, that want popups without a traffic-based bill and are happy for lead capture to run through the form plugin they already use.
Side by side
13 attributes| Attribute | OptinMonster | Popup Maker |
|---|---|---|
| Category | Lead Capture | Lead Capture |
| Starting price | $7 per month billed annually ($84 for the first year, then $210 per year at list price) | Free core plugin; Pro from $99 per year for one site ($59.40 in the first year with the 40 percent launch discount), annual billing only |
| Pricing model | Annual subscription priced by monthly campaign impressions and the number of sites, with feature gating as the primary upgrade driver rather than volume alone. Advertised prices are a 60 percent introductory discount valid for the first 12 months; renewal is at list price. Monthly billing exists but is substantially more expensive per month. There is no free plan and no free trial. | Freemium WordPress plugin. The core plugin is free on WordPress.org. Paid Pro and Pro+ licenses are annual, per site count, and auto-renew; there is no monthly option and no traffic or impression meter on any plan. A one-time lifetime license is sold on a separate page. |
| Free plan | No | Free core plugin on WordPress.org with unlimited popups and impressions, auto-open, click, and form-submission triggers, content targeting, and form plugin integrations; no exit intent or scroll trigger |
| Free trial | No | No |
| Best for | Content sites, ecommerce stores, and agencies that already have meaningful traffic and want granular control over which visitor sees which offer, and that will pay for a targeting engine rather than settle for a generic popup builder. | WordPress sites, especially content sites, membership sites, course creators on LifterLMS, and WooCommerce stores, that want popups without a traffic-based bill and are happy for lead capture to run through the form plugin they already use. |
| Setup time | Under an hour to a first live campaign. Installing the script or plugin takes minutes, building a campaign from a template takes about twenty, and connecting an email platform is an OAuth or API key step. Configuring a well-segmented rule set across a real site is a longer project, typically a day of thought rather than a day of work. | Minutes to install and a first popup within the hour. Install from the plugin directory, create a popup, pick a theme, set a trigger and conditions, and paste in a form from your form plugin. Pro and Pro+ add a license key and extension install. |
| Learning curve | Low for building a campaign, moderate for the rules engine. The editor is conventional drag and drop. The skill that takes time is display-rule discipline: deciding what each audience segment should see, setting cookie durations so people are not shown the same thing repeatedly, and resisting the urge to run five campaigns at once on the same page. | Low for WordPress users, moderate for anyone new to WordPress. Themes, triggers, conditions, and cookies are four separate concepts, and the cookie settings are the part new users most often get wrong, which the vendor's documentation covers directly. |
| Platforms | Any website (JavaScript embed script), WordPress (official plugin), Shopify, BigCommerce, WooCommerce, Magento, Squarespace, Wix, Google Tag Manager | WordPress plugin (WordPress 6.7 or later, PHP 7.4 or later), WooCommerce, Easy Digital Downloads, LifterLMS |
| Compliance | GDPR, CCPA | GPL-licensed open source core, Data stored in the site's own WordPress database |
| Founded | 2013 | 2014 |
| Headquarters | West Palm Beach, Florida, United States (fully distributed team) | East Palatka, Florida, United States |
| Ownership | Owned by Awesome Motive, Inc.; bootstrapped and privately held | Privately held by Code Atlantic LLC |
Strengths and limitations
OptinMonster
Strengths
- The deepest display rules engine in the small-business lead capture category, combining page, behavior, referrer, cookie, JavaScript, geographic, and visit-history conditions with and/or logic.
- Exit intent that has been refined over a decade, including mobile handling that does not depend on a cursor.
- One global script or plugin covers a whole site, so campaigns can be launched and changed forever after without a code deploy.
- Unlimited campaigns and unlimited subscribers on every tier; the meter is impressions, not list size, which is unusually friendly for a growing list.
Limitations
- No free plan and no free trial. Evaluation requires paying up front and relying on a 14-day refund, which is out of step with the rest of the category.
- Renewal pricing is roughly 2.5 times the advertised introductory rate, and the discount framing makes that easy to miss at purchase.
- Exit-Intent technology, the feature the product is best known for, is locked to the third tier; A/B testing is locked to the second. The advertised $7 plan is not a usable version of the product for most buyers.
- Impression-based metering means bot and crawler traffic can consume the allowance without producing a single lead, a complaint that recurs in user reviews.
Popup Maker
Strengths
- No traffic meter on any plan, so the cost is flat whether the site serves ten thousand or ten million pageviews.
- A genuinely useful free plugin with unlimited popups and impressions, installed on more than 700,000 sites per WordPress.org.
- Among the most reviewed WordPress plugins in the category: 4,508 ratings on WordPress.org averaging 98 out of 100, with 4,278 five-star reviews.
- Deep WordPress fit: targeting by post type, taxonomy, user role, and login status, and integrations with nearly every major form plugin.
Limitations
- WordPress only; there is no version for Shopify, Wix, Squarespace, or custom sites.
- No A/B testing is listed on any plan, which leaves offer testing to manual comparisons of analytics.
- Exit intent and scroll triggers require Pro, so the free plugin is closer to a modal tool than a full lead capture tool.
- The editor is WordPress-native rather than a drag-and-drop canvas, so design flexibility depends on the block editor and theme settings.
Pricing compared
OptinMonster
Annual subscription priced by monthly campaign impressions and the number of sites, with feature gating as the primary upgrade driver rather than volume alone. Advertised prices are a 60 percent introductory discount valid for the first 12 months; renewal is at list price. Monthly billing exists but is substantially more expensive per month. There is no free plan and no free trial.
- Basic$7
- Plus$19
- Pro$29
- Growth$49
Judged on first-year cost, OptinMonster is inexpensive for what it does: a $348 Pro plan that recovers a handful of abandoned carts a month pays for itself many times over on any store with real order values. Judged on renewal cost and gating honesty, it is a harder sell, because the plan most buyers need is $870 a year at list and the cheapest tiers withhold the two features (exit intent and A/B testing) that make the category work. Against free or near-free popup plugins the case rests entirely on the display rules engine; if you will never write a rule more complex than 'show on all pages after 5 seconds', you are paying for capability you will not use. If you will segment by referrer, cart value, geography, and visit count, nothing at this price point matches it.
Popup Maker
Freemium WordPress plugin. The core plugin is free on WordPress.org. Paid Pro and Pro+ licenses are annual, per site count, and auto-renew; there is no monthly option and no traffic or impression meter on any plan. A one-time lifetime license is sold on a separate page.
- Free$0
- Pro$99
- Pro+$249
- Pro Lifetime$299
For a WordPress site, this is the best price-to-traffic ratio in the category by a distance, because traffic does not enter the price at all. The free plugin handles click-to-open popups, announcements, and content-targeted signup offers with no bill, and $99 a year buys exit intent, scroll triggers, analytics, and advanced targeting for a site of any size, where a hosted tool metered on pageviews would charge that much in a month or two at scale. Pro+ at $249 a year is the cheapest path in the category to popup-level revenue attribution for WooCommerce. The costs are elsewhere: no A/B testing, no life outside WordPress, a builder that is less visual than the hosted tools, and lead handling that depends on the form plugin you pair it with.
Editorial verdict on each
OptinMonster
OptinMonster is still the reference product in onsite lead capture, and the reason is not the popups, which anyone can build, but the rules engine behind them. Being able to say show this offer only to Google Ads traffic on product pages, only when the cart is above a threshold, only on a second visit, and only as the visitor leaves, is a genuine capability gap over the cheaper tools, and for a store or publisher with real traffic it pays back quickly. The company is bootstrapped, profitable, and unlikely to disappear. The reservations are commercial rather than technical: no free plan and no trial in a category where free plans are standard, a renewal price roughly 2.5 times the advertised one, and gating that puts exit intent (the thing people buy it for) on the third tier. Go in knowing the real price is the Pro or Growth renewal figure, not the number on the pricing page, and it is a sound purchase. Go in expecting the $7 plan to be the product and you will be disappointed within a week.
Read the full OptinMonster profilePopup Maker
Popup Maker is the obvious first stop for any WordPress site, for a reason no hosted competitor can match: traffic never enters the price. The free plugin handles click-to-open popups, announcements, and content-targeted signup offers at no cost on a site of any size, $99 a year adds exit intent, scroll triggers, analytics, and serious targeting, and $249 a year adds WooCommerce, Easy Digital Downloads, and LifterLMS revenue attribution that hosted tools charge far more for. Its 700,000-plus installs and near-perfect WordPress.org rating show it works. The trade-offs are real, though: it lives only on WordPress, it has no A/B testing, the builder is less visual than the hosted canvases, and lead capture depends on the form plugin you pair it with. For a high-traffic WordPress site that wants exit intent without a meter, buy Pro. For anyone who tests offers systematically or runs on Shopify, look elsewhere.
Read the full Popup Maker profileOptinMonster profile last reviewed 2026-08-23; Popup Maker last reviewed 2026-09-26. Pricing is compiled from public sources and can change without notice. See our methodology.
The best in Lead Capture & Popups
16 trackedLead capture tools convert existing website traffic into contacts using popups, slide-ins, banners, and gamified offers, triggered by behavior such as exit intent, scroll depth, or time on page.
A goal first builder with inline editing puts a live campaign up in fifteen minutes, and no documentation is needed to ship it.
Frequently asked questions
6 questionsWhat is the difference between OptinMonster and Popup Maker?
Popup Maker is the WordPress-native alternative with no traffic meter at all: the core plugin is free with unlimited popups and impressions, and exit intent, scroll triggers, analytics, and advanced targeting cost $99 a year per site on Pro. OptinMonster keeps the deeper rules engine, the larger template library, A/B testing, and a hosted service that works beyond WordPress. For a high-traffic WordPress site on a fixed budget, Popup Maker is hard to beat; for testing-led campaigns or non-WordPress sites, OptinMonster is the one to buy.
Is OptinMonster or Popup Maker cheaper?
OptinMonster starts at $7 per month billed annually ($84 for the first year, then $210 per year at list price). Popup Maker starts at Free core plugin; Pro from $99 per year for one site ($59.40 in the first year with the 40 percent launch discount), annual billing only. The billing models differ, so the entry price is rarely the whole cost. OptinMonster pricing model: Annual subscription priced by monthly campaign impressions and the number of sites, with feature gating as the primary upgrade driver rather than volume alone. Popup Maker pricing model: Freemium WordPress plugin. org. Paid Pro and Pro+ licenses are annual, per site count, and auto-renew; there is no monthly option and no traffic or impression meter on any plan. A one-time lifetime license is sold on a separate page.
Does OptinMonster or Popup Maker have a free plan?
OptinMonster has no free plan. Popup Maker has a free plan. Free core plugin on WordPress.org with unlimited popups and impressions, auto-open, click, and form-submission triggers, content targeting, and form plugin integrations; no exit intent or scroll trigger.
Who should choose OptinMonster?
Content sites, ecommerce stores, and agencies that already have meaningful traffic and want granular control over which visitor sees which offer, and that will pay for a targeting engine rather than settle for a generic popup builder.
Who should choose Popup Maker?
WordPress sites, especially content sites, membership sites, course creators on LifterLMS, and WooCommerce stores, that want popups without a traffic-based bill and are happy for lead capture to run through the form plugin they already use.
What are the best alternatives to OptinMonster and Popup Maker?
SaaSTracker profiles 16 products in Lead Capture & Popups. The Summer 2026 awards in the category went to Hello Bar (Ease of Use). Every profile is compiled from primary sources, so a shortlist can be built from pricing, limitations, and fit rather than from star ratings.
